Endocrine Disruptors – They’re Everywhere! How Can We Better Protect Ourselves From Them?
We hear more and more often about endocrine disruptors (EDs). But do you know what an endocrine disruptor really is? What effects do they have on our health and ecosystems? Where are they found? And what can we do to protect ourselves from them?
The first observations of proven cases due to PE date back to the 1950s. The use of a pesticide, DDT, appears to be harmful to fish and birds. Following contamination with DDT, the disappearance of bald eagles, which became sterile, was observed in California. During this same period, other environmental incidents, such as the disappearance of seals in the Baltic Sea or alligators with micro penises, were observed. In 1991, a group of scientists met in the United States to study the effects of chemicals on hormones. The term "endocrine disruptor" was defined.
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), an ED has been defined as "An exogenous substance (or mixture) that alters the functions of the endocrine system, and thus induces health effects in an intact organism, its descendants or subpopulations."
The endocrine system is composed of a set of glands (e.g. thyroid, adrenal, pancreatic) which produce and release hormones (e.g. melatonin, progesterone, testosterone, insulin) which will control various regulatory processes of the body such as reproduction, growth, reaction to stress, or metabolism.
All vertebrates have the same endocrine glands as humans. So we could infer that what is not good for the endocrine system of a fish, a frog or a bird is probably not going to be good for the endocrine system of humans.
To date, we are aware of more than a thousand different potential PEs (bisphenol, phthalates, pesticides, perfluorinated compounds, neonicotinoids, flame retardants, etc.). Most of these molecules come from human activity, but they can also be found naturally in the environment (e.g. phytoestrogens found in certain plants).
PEs are omnipresent in our daily lives. We are all contaminated. They can be found in water, air, pesticides, plastic packaging, dust, cleaning products, food, medicines and cosmetics, among other things. They are everywhere!
PE molecules can act in two different ways. Either they mimic natural hormones, activating a receptor that will trigger exaggerated or unwanted responses or situations, or they place themselves on the receptors, blocking them, preventing natural hormones from attaching to them and doing their job.
An increase in the incidence of diseases related to the hormonal system has been observed in recent decades (prostate, breast, uterine, ovarian cancers, obesity, type 2 diabetes, deterioration of sperm quality, increase in the number of low birth weight babies, precocious puberty, increase in diseases associated with thyroid dysfunction, etc.).
In some cases, a causal link has been established with EDCs. The vast majority of scientists agree that EDCs are capable of interfering with the hormonal system even at tiny doses and many studies establish possible associations between EDC exposure and these diseases. However, it is still difficult to provide evidence regarding their effects on humans.
There are, however, multiple examples of proven disturbances in wildlife and experimental data in animals that provide additional support for the hypothesis of a correlation between exposure to PE and these diseases in humans.
The best solution to stop the rise of these diseases would be stricter regulation of products containing PE. Unfortunately, as the economic stakes are enormous and the power of the various lobbies extremely powerful, laws are struggling to be put in place and the European Union is slow to legislate on legislative measures to regulate PE.
From a toxicological point of view, standards have been set for many substances. But endocrinologists agree that EDCs can disrupt or interfere with our hormonal system even at infinitesimal doses. Regulations on EDCs should then be defined on their mode of action and not on the basis of their toxicity. Current laws therefore do not protect consumers enough. The precautionary principle should be applied in all cases.
So what can we do on our side?
Even though the impact is limited, we can still try to reduce our exposure to PE. It is estimated that 80% of our exposure to PE comes from our diet (e.g. pesticides, plastic packaging, microwave popcorn bags, non-stick coatings on Teflon pans, etc.)
Cosmetics are not spared. A study carried out by the Noteo institute in partnership with the Réseau environnement santé (RES) shows that 40% of hygiene-beauty products contain at least 1 endocrine disruptor.
In order to avoid them, it is essential to learn how to read labels and spot them. Here is a non-exhaustive list of the most common PEs that can be found in cosmetic products:
The famous parabens:
Although parabens get a bad rap, not all of them are dangerous. Some are harmless to health, such as methylparaben and ethylparaben. They are even among the most effective preservatives.
On the other hand, you should avoid butylparaben, propylparaben, potassium butylparaben and potassium propylparaben.
BHT and BHA
Used as preservatives in all kinds of hygiene/beauty products, they are suspected of being carcinogenic (especially BHA)
Phthalates
They can also hide under the INCI name "parfum", "fragrance" or "aroma" in various cosmetic products. They are used to denature the alcohol present in perfumes (the law requires manufacturers to denature alcohol to make it unfit for consumption! Phthalates are a cheap solution). Perfume recipes are considered trade secrets, so we will not be able to know what they are composed of.
They are also found in nail polishes. In this case, they will serve as a fixing agent that will prevent the polish from flaking.
PEG or PPG
Besides their environmental issues, they are also known to disrupt the endocrine system. They are often followed by a number (molecular weight) or 1-4 dioxane
Aluminum salts
They are mainly found in deodorants. They tighten the pores of the skin and block perspiration. Although there is much controversy on the subject, they are suspected of increasing the risks of breast cancer or other degenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson's. Studies on mice have shown that mammary cells exposed in vitro to aluminum salts develop the ability to form tumors and metastases in mice. Harmful effects have also been demonstrated on human mammary cells.
Aluminum salts are found under the names: aluminum stearates, aluminum hydroxide, aluminum zirconium, pentachlorohydrate.
UV filters
There are two types of UV filters: chemical synthesis filters (banned in the organic industry) and mineral filters.
Some chemical UV screens can act as PEs, including the following:
Oxybenzone (Benzophenone-3)
Homosalate
3-benzylidene camphor
4-Methylbenzylidene Camphor
4,4-dihydroxybenzophenone
Benzophenone-1
Benzophenone-2
Octyl Methoxycinnamate also called Ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate
(OMC) or Octinoxate
Octocrylene
Silicones
Although they are not recommended for environmental reasons and because they are occlusive and weaken the skin, most silicones are not harmful to health with the exception of cyclopentasiloxane and cyclotetrasiloxane which have shown endocrine disrupting properties.
PEs are unfortunately not the only problems that can be encountered in the composition of cosmetic products. There are a multitude of unsavory substances used in cosmetics, potentially toxic or not ecological. The article "Why and how to decipher the labels of your cosmetics" can provide you with some tips and prevent you from being fooled by marketing traps. You can also consultthe list of ingredients that should absolutely be avoided in cosmetics . It is unfortunately impossible to list all the unsavory substances but this list includes the most common ones.
References:
- Endocrine Disruptors, These products that attack our hormones, Dr. Olivier Kah
- When our environment attacks our hormones, Conference, Dr. Olivier Kah
- Detoxify yourself, this guide can save your life, Dr Véronique Vasseur and Clémence Thévenoz
- UFC, Que Choisir, Fact sheets on toxic molecules to avoid
- The Truth About Cosmetics, Rita Sitiens
- The five myths about sunscreen products, The Truth about cosmetics, Rita Sitiens
- Endocrine disruptors: general considerations, and examples of Bisphenol A and phthalates, Prof. Jacques Diezi
- Cosmetics, How to navigate, Ariane Warlin
- A Bon Entendeur - abe.ch - Broadcast on aluminium salts – Interview with Prof Mandriota