Skip to content

Formulated and handmade in Lausanne · 60-day money-back guarantee

Popular searches

← All articles

Can we really trust organic labels?

Peut-on vraiment se fier aux labels bio ?

During the process of creating my brand, I decided to take a closer look at the ins and outs of organic labels in cosmetics.

As I know that it is sometimes difficult to find your way around as a consumer, I wanted to share with you the results of my research.

There are many labels on the market, which can be misleading for consumers.

Each of these labels has its own specifications, which can be very different from one label to another.

Let’s be clear, an organic label sells!

Some organic cosmetic brands do not hesitate to use misleading marketing techniques and use the label as a marketing argument devoid of any real commitment.

Unfortunately, not all organic labels guarantee the same quality.

Some certification systems impose stricter standards than others. For example, some labels allow the use of surfactants (cleansing or foaming agents) or certain synthetic substances that are more or less irritating to the skin.

Some require at least 95% to 100% organic ingredients in the product, while others only require 10%. Given these differences in requirements, some organic products could not be certified under another label where the quality requirements are much higher.

It should be noted that certain substances such as clay, water or plant substances from wild cultivation, although completely natural and ecological, cannot be labelled because they come from nature and not from organic cultivation.

In summary, it would therefore be wrong to say that all organic cosmetics are without reproach, but an organic label nevertheless ensures, in most cases , that the product does not contain ingredients that are controversial for health or the environment.

For some reasons, such as financial (labels have a certain cost) or ideological, some brands choose not to be labeled. Not all brands that do not have organic labels are necessarily bad! It often happens that some "natural cosmetics" products contain more organic ingredients than products certified as "organic cosmetics".

The choice of &The Green.

For our part, we thought long and hard about it... Label or no label? We decided not to label ourselves but created our own specifications that go beyond existing organic labels. We created our own specifications. You can find them on the page https://www.andthegreen.com/plus-bio-qu-le-bio

Here is a list of some of the most common organic labels on the market and their main characteristics:

Cosmebio

Cosmebio is a French association with an international vocation. It was created in 2002 by around ten cosmetic laboratories. For this label:

- At least 95% of plant ingredients must be of plant origin

- At least 20% of all ingredients must come from organic farming

This label allows the use of some synthetic preservatives and Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS), a chemical surfactant that is polluting and aggressive for the skin. Palm oil derivatives are allowed.

Ecocert

Ecocert is a French control and certification body. To obtain the "Ecological and Organic Cosmetics" label, at least 95% of the total ingredients must be ingredients of natural origin. 95% of the plants present in the formula must come from organic farming. The share of ingredients from synthesis in the finished product can only represent a maximum of 5% of all the ingredients and, in total, 10% of the minimum ingredients in the finished product must be organic.

Cosmos-standard

The COSMOS standard was developed by various certification bodies (BDIH, COSMEBIO, ECOCERT, ICEA and SOIL ASSOCIATION in 2010 with a view to establishing common requirements and definitions for organic and/or natural cosmetics. The various logos of the certification bodies will not disappear but may be supplemented by the “Cosmos Natural” or “Cosmos Organic” label. The Cosmos Natural label has no requirement concerning the percentage of organic ingredients. As for Cosmos Organic, at least 20% of the ingredients in the finished product must be organic. 10% is permitted for certain products with a high quantity of water (not labelable) such as shower gels or shampoos.

Nature & Progress

Nature & Progrès is a non-profit association, bringing together producers, processors and consumers. This is a very demanding label. As far as possible, all ingredients must be organic. No palm oil.

Demeter

Demeter is an international label that certifies cosmetics from biodynamic agriculture, which is more demanding than organic farming. It is a label that requires compliance with strict standards. At least 90% of raw materials of plant or animal origin must be, as far as possible, Demeter certified.

Beware of the new ISO 16128 standard

A new international standard for organic and natural products has been introduced and came into force in January 2018. It further complicates the task of consumers in their choices and complicates the readability of labels. This new standard is creating controversy among organic professionals who denounce a potential deception for consumers that only benefits cosmetic manufacturers.

The initial objective of this standard was to harmonize languages ​​and set common guidelines for natural and organic cosmetics, as well as their ingredients. The standard does not specify whether the product is organic or not, but only provides information on its natural or organic content.

This new standard is far from unanimous.

In fact, it does not prohibit the presence of certain controversial and polemical components, such as parabens, petrochemical and plastic derivatives, phenoxyethanol, EDTA, BHT, ingredients from GMOs, etc. According to the standard, an ingredient can be considered as a "natural derivative", as long as it is composed of 50% natural raw materials and therefore falls within the percentage of naturalness of the product and is legally affixed to the labels.

This new standard therefore allows brands greater marketing creativity and encourages them to do even more greenwashing....

The only solution to avoid being fooled is to learn to read and decipher labels. I will give you some keys to do this in a future blog post......

Leave a comment

Your bag

  • Your bag is empty.

Total 0 CHF

60-day money-back guarantee